The American Medical Association, leading a diverse coalition of 62 prominent healthcare organizations, has formally submitted a petition to congressional leadership demanding the inclusion of four essential Medicare reforms in the upcoming year-end legislative package. This collective action comes at a critical juncture for the United States healthcare infrastructure, as physician practices face an impending 2.8% payment cut scheduled to take effect on January 1, 2025. The coalition, which includes the American Academy of Family Physicians, the American College of Cardiology, and the American Psychiatric Association, argues that the current trajectory of Medicare reimbursement is unsustainable and threatens the very foundation of patient access to care, particularly in rural and underserved communities.
The letter addressed to House and Senate leaders highlights a stark economic reality: when adjusted for inflation in practice costs, Medicare physician payments have effectively plummeted by approximately 33% since 2001. This fiscal erosion occurs at a time when the costs of running a medical practice—including labor, medical supplies, rent, and technology—have surged to record highs. By urging Congress to act during the "lame-duck" session following the recent elections, the coalition seeks to stabilize a system that many providers claim is nearing a breaking point.
The Four Pillars of the Coalition’s Reform Proposal
The coalition’s request is structured around four specific policy interventions designed to provide immediate relief and long-term stability to the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule. These reforms address both the immediate threat of declining revenue and the systemic flaws in how Medicare calculates and updates provider compensation.
First and foremost, the coalition is calling for the full reversal of the 2.8% cut to the Medicare physician payment conversion factor. This cut was finalized by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) in its 2025 Physician Fee Schedule final rule. Without congressional intervention, this reduction will exacerbate the financial strain on practices already reeling from years of stagnant or declining reimbursement.
Second, the organizations are advocating for a permanent, annual inflationary update to Medicare physician payments. Unlike almost every other provider category within Medicare—such as hospitals, skilled nursing facilities, and hospice care—physicians do not receive an automatic annual update based on the Medicare Economic Index (MEI). The MEI measures the price growth of inputs required to provide physician services. The coalition argues that the absence of this mechanism is the primary driver of the 33% real-term decline in payments over the last two decades.
Third, the letter urges Congress to reform the Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS). Originally intended to transition the Medicare system toward value-based care, MIPS has become a source of significant administrative burden for many physicians. The coalition contends that the current structure of MIPS is overly complex, lacks clinical relevance for many specialties, and creates financial uncertainty rather than incentivizing genuine quality improvements.
Finally, the coalition is seeking a fix for the "budget neutrality" triggers within the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule. Under current law, any significant increase in the valuation of certain services must be offset by across-the-board cuts to all other services to ensure the total spend remains budget-neutral. The coalition is calling for an increase in the threshold that triggers these automatic cuts, which currently stands at $20 million—a figure that has not been adjusted for inflation since its inception decades ago.
Historical Context and the Erosion of Physician Reimbursement
To understand the urgency of the coalition’s letter, one must examine the legislative history of Medicare payments. For years, the Medicare system was governed by the Sustainable Growth Rate (SGR) formula, which frequently triggered massive, double-digit cuts that Congress had to "patch" annually. In 2015, the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act (MACRA) was passed with bipartisan support to replace the SGR with a more stable system.
However, while MACRA eliminated the threat of 20% cuts, it replaced them with a period of near-zero payment updates. Since the implementation of MACRA, the gap between the cost of providing care and the reimbursement received has widened significantly. According to data from the AMA, while the cost of running a practice has risen by 47% since 2001, physician payments have increased by only 11% in nominal terms. When the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and the MEI are factored in, the purchasing power of Medicare payments has effectively withered.
This trend stands in sharp contrast to other sectors of the healthcare economy. Hospitals and other facilities generally receive annual updates tied to inflation, allowing them to adjust for rising labor costs and supply chain disruptions. Physicians, often operating as small business owners, are left to absorb these costs without a corresponding increase in revenue, leading to what many experts describe as a "quiet crisis" in outpatient care.
Data and Economic Implications for Practice Sustainability
The economic pressure on physician practices has far-reaching consequences for the broader healthcare landscape. Small, independent, and rural practices are particularly vulnerable. Unlike large health systems, these entities lack the scale to negotiate higher rates with private insurers to offset Medicare losses. As the cost of providing care exceeds the reimbursement received, many independent physicians are forced to make difficult choices: limiting the number of new Medicare patients they accept, reducing staff, or closing their doors entirely.

One of the most significant outcomes of this financial pressure is the rapid consolidation of the healthcare market. When independent practices become financially unviable, they are frequently acquired by large hospital systems or private equity firms. Data from the Physicians Advocacy Institute indicates that as of 2024, nearly 77% of physicians in the United States are employed by hospitals or corporate entities.
Consolidation often leads to higher overall healthcare costs for both patients and the government. Services performed in a hospital-owned facility are frequently billed at much higher rates than the same services performed in an independent physician’s office due to "facility fees." Consequently, the coalition argues that failing to support independent physician practices inadvertently drives up Medicare spending in the long run by pushing care into more expensive settings.
Statements from Leadership and Stakeholder Reactions
The coalition’s message was reinforced by AMA President Dr. Willie Underwood III, who emphasized the bipartisan nature of the requested reforms. "Medicare patients need access to physicians, and physicians need a payment system that works," Dr. Underwood stated. "Congress has an opportunity to protect access to care and give physician practices the stability they need to keep serving Medicare patients. These four reforms are practical, bipartisan steps Congress can take now to strengthen Medicare and protect patients."
The inclusion of the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) in the coalition underscores the impact on primary care. Primary care physicians often serve as the first point of contact for Medicare beneficiaries, managing chronic conditions and coordinating complex care. The AAFP has long maintained that without a stable payment structure, the primary care workforce will continue to shrink as medical students opt for higher-paying specialties to manage their educational debt.
Similarly, the American College of Cardiology and the American Psychiatric Association highlighted the specialized needs of their patient populations. For cardiologists, the budget neutrality adjustments often result in cuts to procedural codes that are essential for treating heart disease. For psychiatrists, the lack of inflationary updates hinders the ability to expand mental health services at a time when the nation is facing a mental health crisis.
While congressional leaders have yet to issue a formal response to the letter, there is some legislative momentum. In the House of Representatives, several bipartisan bills have been introduced that align with the coalition’s goals. For instance, the "Strengthening Medicare for Patients and Providers Act" (H.R. 2474) aims to provide a permanent inflation-based update to the conversion factor tied to the MEI.
The Path Forward in the Lame-Duck Session
The timing of the letter is strategic. The "lame-duck" session—the period between the November election and the swearing-in of the new Congress in January—is traditionally a time when large, "must-pass" spending packages are negotiated. These packages often include various "extenders" or temporary fixes for healthcare policies.
However, the coalition is pushing for more than just another temporary patch. They are advocating for structural changes that move away from the cycle of annual uncertainty. The proposed reform to the budget neutrality threshold, for example, would prevent minor changes in coding from triggering major across-the-board cuts, providing a level of predictability that has been missing from the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule for years.
The legislative hurdles remain significant. Any increase in Medicare spending must be reconciled with broader budgetary concerns and competing priorities, such as funding for the Department of Defense and social safety net programs. Furthermore, the political climate remains highly polarized, although healthcare provider payment issues have historically found common ground across the aisle.
Broader Impact on Patient Access and Quality of Care
The ultimate stakeholders in this legislative debate are the more than 65 million Medicare beneficiaries. For these individuals, the stability of physician payments translates directly into the availability of care. If physicians continue to exit the Medicare program or retire early due to burnout and financial stress, wait times for appointments will increase, and the distance patients must travel for specialized care will grow.
In rural areas, where the physician-to-patient ratio is already low, the impact of a 2.8% cut could be catastrophic. Rural clinics often operate on the thinnest of margins, and even a minor reduction in revenue can lead to the loss of essential services. By addressing the four points outlined in their letter, the coalition of 62 organizations is not merely seeking a raise for doctors; they are advocating for the preservation of the national healthcare infrastructure.
As the year-end deadline approaches, the pressure on Congress to act will likely intensify. The coalition’s letter serves as a formal warning that the current trajectory is unsustainable. Whether lawmakers will prioritize these reforms in the final legislative push of the year remains to be seen, but the unity of 62 major healthcare organizations sends a clear message: the time for temporary fixes has passed, and the need for comprehensive Medicare payment reform is urgent.
